The question is simple enough.

And my answer is simple enough too: Haruna! 

Haru's make-ups are light and simple yet they give her face a natural, youthful and vibrant appearance. I like the pinkish cheeks and minimal lips and eyes cosmetics. In a way, her style not only makes her face look pretty but also cute. I had once a friendly argument with a fellow SCANDAL fan on who's cuter between younger Haru and older Haru and while young Haru is definitely cute, I argued that older Haru is cuter because her makeups make her cuteness glow.

Both Mami and Rina have that pink make-up below their eyes and just above their cheeks that sometimes I think is good, sometimes not... especially with Mami's which sometimes is too 'heavy' for me. I'm not really a big fan of heavy cosmetics so I'm also not a fan of Mami's Egyptian-like eye make-ups and all those time all four of them have too much going on on their faces. In general, I like them with light make-up.

Funny thing tho. I can't seem to remember consciously critiquing Tomi's make-up.

So yup, Haru's mine. Who's yours? And why?

I have always loved Tomomi's natural look, but she can do sultry when she wants to.

You said it's heavy, but I love it when Mami goes really pink around her eyes. It makes her look like she's drunk or almost ill, but I find that so attractive. 

So I'd go for Mami.

@tonymiller did you just praise Tomi while voting for Rina?
.omg. 

@peachclub yeah I know there will be fans of her make up style. Like I said, I think it's too heavy but there are times it looks good on her like this one.
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

peachclub wrote:You said it's heavy, but I love it when Mami goes really pink around her eyes. It makes her look like she's drunk or almost ill, but I find that so attractive. 

Their zombie make up for the Halloween performance must've been a real turn on, then! [You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]

I did like that zombie make up. It wasn't like "Oh, that looks so pretty, she should do that make up everyday", but it looked great on her, I liked it.

It's toss up for me between Haruna and Tomomi, but I voted for Haruna.  I can't think of any time thinking she had too much going on her face.  I prefer the "less is more" approach.

This is a difficult question because they are all very charming.
If I want a natural look, I choose Tomomi. She is always beautiful with a light makeup ... but I really like Mami, her make-up can sometimes be a bit fanciful but it gives her an incredible style!

It's a tie between Gene Simmons and Ace Frehley.

Boom-tish! I kid, of course. But I really would kill to see the girls in KISS make-up (with their natural hair colour, of course). Anyone here got the photoshop skills? You'd be doing me a huge favour...

Er, back on topic:

I'm in the less is more camp, but it is fun to see the girls get all glammed up now and again.

Not gonna research, just voting Tomomi because she is always pretty :b

I love the make up style of all of them, buuut, I really looove Mami style, is so cool and nice, and really personal for her.

Disclaimer: I'm neither a make-up artist nor an expert. This response is based merely on my untrained artist's eye.

Comparing make-up styles to different women is like comparing apples to oranges. It's also unfair to pick the best looking SCANDAL member wearing make-up because of their beauty is unique to one another. So, I decline to cast my vote. 

Each women has different type of facial shapes and features. For example, Haruna and Mami looked amazing with dark, smoky make-up including the kohl eyeliner from 2009 to 2011 because of their strong facial features and pointed nose. As they mature however, their facial features becoming more subtle and their facial shapes are becoming thinner. So, natural matte look will look better for them. 

The natural shimmer look with shades of pink looks amazing on Rina. Tomomi can easily pull-off a either a natural shimmer or natural matte look with beige or orange-tinted lips. In my opinion, smoky make-up were too much for their skin tone and angelic looks.

Haru has the best make-up, her make-up makes her face natural.
 
Mami’s make-up gives her an incredible style.