maharizm wrote:I am looking forward to hear what the other two guitars sound like. Like ichiruki!, perhaps the tinny tone on that YouTube vid has lots to do with what the video guy has on his setting on his effects/amp/amp sim/whatever.
He seems to be recording through a Yamaha THR10, which I have as well for that purpose, and generally it's a great recording amp/interface, but you do need to be careful with the settings. The THR10 is a modeling amp that's ridiculously customizable and also has a straight "DI" recording mode.
To me his tone sounds like a DI recording. If you use the DI mode, then you need to make sure you add your own modeling in software. He might have recorded in DI mode thinking that was the "purest" tone, which technically it is, but no guitar ever sounds like that when played through an amp (which is how electric guitars are always played). You're literally just hearing the raw electrical performance of the pickups alone. Even my American Jazzmaster sounds similar to this using DI with nothing added.
My other amp is a Fender Twin Reverb, which is pretty much the Fender reference amp (and Haruna's preferred amp before doing her Shinos promotional deal) and that's what I'm basing my tone judgments on. There's an obvious difference between the single coils and the Hot Rails. The Hot Rails is probably the "least good" sounding pickup I've heard on that amp (I'm trying to be nice), and I've played about 10 or 12 guitars through this same amp. The single coils sound pretty good, though.
What are your thoughts on the that black rubber/foam strip (is this a rubber mute?) between the AOM and the trem, spacecadet? (Personally I have NO idea why she has it - could it be to get rid of the rattly feel when you strum the guitar?)
Personally I hate those, but with any signature model I think the goal should be for it to be as close to the real thing as possible, and this is nondestructive so you may as well do it. The purpose of it is to stop the harmonics that happen behind the bridge. The reason most Jazzmaster/Jaguar players hate seeing people do that is that that's part of what makes the JM and Jag sound distinctive; no other Fender solid body guitars have those extra harmonics.
But I guess her goal with this guitar was not really to get a Jazzmaster, but a Strat with a Jazzmaster body shape. So the foam would help with making it sound more like a Strat.
Most people just use regular weatherstripping foam and hers looks like that too. You can buy it at home improvement stores.